Tuesday, March 5, 2013

A Midrashic Look at Red Lipstick

I started writing this post a few weeks ago when this article was published in Lilith. In it Dasi Frucher writes about her daily morning ritual which makes her feel, “all at once powerful, beautiful and uniquely feminine.” With the simple act of smearing red lipstick on her lips she is reminded of her potential and strength and urges herself to be her best. But, if her red lipstick is an acceptable component of her professional life in which she studies non-profit management in NYU, it has become a matter of debate in her religious studies in Yeshivat Maharat. During a lunch break she and a colleague were discussing tzniut:

Considering the controversial space the Yeshiva already occupies in a broader global Orthodox context, we agreed that though our clothing choices should not completely hide our the fact that we are, in fact, sexual beings, that anything too provocative was inappropriate.
I paused for a moment and gestured towards my lips.
“What about my lipstick,?” I asked nervously, almost unwilling to hear her response.
She paused.
“Maybe pick a different color,” she said.

There’s a seemingly innocuous passuk in Parshat Vayakhel which is made pregnant with meaning by the Midrash Tanhuma.

וַיַּעַשׂ אֵת הַכִּיּוֹר נְחֹשֶׁת וְאֵת כַּנּוֹ נְחֹשֶׁת בְּמַרְאֹת הַצֹּבְאֹת אֲשֶׁר צָבְאוּ פֶּתַח אֹהֶל מוֹעֵד:
And he made the sink (of the Tabernacle) out of brass and its base out of brass from the mirrors of the legions who served at the entrance to the tent of meeting.

Although the verse lends itself easily to a simple interpretation, the Midrash Tanhuma saw fit to expand upon the word “legions.” If elsewhere in the Biblical narrative of the departure from Egypt the word “legions” is seen as an indication of the large mass of people who left Egypt (as opposed to the small family which arrived there), then here too it could have a similar meaning. Therefore, the passuk is reinterpreted to mean not “the mirrors of the legion,” but, “the mirrors which caused the legions.” While obviously this reading is not the original intent, it allows for an intriguing narrative that “fills in the blanks” to give us more information on the connection between mirrors and population change.

אתה מוצא בשעה שהיו ישראל בעבודת פרך במצרים גזר עליהם פרעה שלא יהיו ישנים בבתיהן שלא יהיו משמשין מטותיהן, אמר רבי שמעון בר חלפתא מהו היו בנות ישראל עושות יורדות לשאוב מים מן היאור והקב"ה היה מזמין להם דגים קטנים בתוך כדיהן והן מוכרות ומבשלות מהן ולוקחות מהן יין והולכות לשדה ומאכילות את בעליהן שם שנא' (שמות א) בכל עבודה בשדה, משהיו אוכלין ושותין נוטלות המראות ומביטות בהן עם בעליהן זאת אומרת אני נאה ממך וזה אומר אני נאה ממך ומתוך כך היו מרגילין עצמן לידי תאוה ופרין ורבין... בזכות אותן המראות שהיו מראות לבעליהן ומרגילות אותן לידי תאוה מתוך הפרך העמידו כל הצבאות שנאמר (שם /שמות/ יב) יצאו כל צבאות ה' מארץ מצרים ואומר הוציא ה' את בני ישראל מארץ מצרים על צבאותם (שם /שמות י"ב/), כיון שאמר לו הקדוש ברוך הוא למשה לעשות את המשכן עמדו כל ישראל ונתנדבו... הביאו בזריזות הכל, אמרו הנשים מה יש לנו ליתן בנדבת המשכן, עמדו והביאו את המראות והלכו להן אצל משה, כשראה משה אותן המראות זעף בהן, אמר להם לישראל טולו מקלות ושברו שוקיהן של אלו, המראות למה הן צריכין, א"ל הקב"ה למשה משה על אלו אתה מבזה, המראות האלו הן העמידו כל הצבאות הללו במצרים טול מהן ועשה מהן כיור נחשת וכנו לכהנים שממנו יהיו מתקדשין הכהנים...
When Yisrael were performing labor in Egypt, Pharoh decreed that they (i.e. the men) should not sleep at home so that they should not sleep with their wives. Rabbi Shimon b. Halafta said, What did the Bnot Yisrael do? They would go down to the Nile and draw water and God would cause little fish to go into their pails and they would sell and cook them and buy with the money earned from them wine. And they would go out to the fields and feed their husbands there, as it says, “in all the work of the fields.” And when they were eating and drinking they would take out their mirrors and look at them with their husbands and she would say, “I’m prettier than you” and he would say, “I’m prettier than you.” And thus they would awaken their desire and multiply... In the merit of those mirrors that they would show their husbands and awaken their desire despite the labor they created all the legions, as it says, “all the legions of God went out from Egypt” and it says, “God took Bnei Yisrael from the land of Egypt as legions.” When God told Moshe to make the Tabernacle all of Yisrael came and donated... they brought everything hastily, and the women said, “What do we have to give for a donation to the Tabernacle?” They got up and they brought their mirrors and took them to Moshe, and when Moshe saw their mirrors he was angry with them and he told Yisrael, “Get rods and break the legs of these [women], for why do they need mirrors?” God said to Moshe, “These you are disgracing?! These mirrors created all these legions in Egypt. Take them and make with them a sink and its base for the Priests and from it the Priests will make themselves holy.

Although this story has become a popular one, largely due to its inclusion in the commentary of Rashi, I think it is often only given a cursory perusal without any real concern for its meaning.

One important note is the primary role of the woman as an accomplice to Yisrael. In other words, the male population is considered the “real” nation - they are the laborers, the ones who cannot sleep in their homes, and they are the ones who left en masse from Egypt - and “Bnot Yisrael” play a supporting rule - enticing and birthing them. This becomes very obvious as we approach the main elements of the plot, the women wonder to themselves what they have to donate, supporting characters don’t have any physical belongings. Finally, in the first organized Religious Feminist campaign they band together and donate their relatively valueless brass (compared to the gold, silver, and gems being donated by their men) mirrors.

Not unlike Religious Feminists today, however, these women are forced to prove the worth of their actions to a suspicious leadership. Moshe tells the men to beat their wives, after all there is no place for vanity and self-beautification in the holy camps of Israel. However, God himself intervenes and explains the significance of these mirrors. The evil inclination was not the driving force in these women’s grooming, they were using them to entice their husbands. In other words, even within this independent attempt to be included in the building of the Tabernacle, the women are once again relegated to their role as supporting characters. This story makes it crystal clear: The Women of Israel cannot be sexual beings unless it’s what the Men of Israel need.

A topic I’ve thought a lot about over the years is the relationship between sexuality and gender identity in the context of Judaism. When I was in seminary (and really even already in high school) the desire to be a Torah scholar translated into a weird attempt to “masculanize” myself. My primary models of great scholars were men and therefore emulation became, unwittingly, a submission of my female-ness to the cause. I called it being “tzanua,” but it was really more a point of view which assumed that my sexuality was inherently problematic (not unlike the voice of Moshe in the Tanhuma) and which extended far beyond what modesty required of me. When I stopped being religious I discovered lipstick, fashion, and an array of other things which I had previously belittled as feminine trifles. This may have been my own unique experience, but when I look back at the people with whom I was surrounded I think it was something that was shared by many of us, if not our teachers as well.

As a secular Feminist too, the relationship to sexuality is complex. Is there such a thing as sexuality outside the context of
The Other? Can my desire to groom myself, to dress a certain way, etc. be divorced from the reality of the admiration I might glean from the opposite gender? The balance is difficult to strike and seems to be a lifelong battle between embracing one’s femininity without inviting or engaging objectification. As per usual, I don’t have answers, only an avalanche of questions that assault me every time I look in the mirror. 



Friday, October 26, 2012

A Different Voice

My favorite thing about this blog has absolutely nothing to do with my own writing, and everything to do with the dozens of messages and comments I’ve gotten from others. I have gotten letters of support, people who need or want a sounding board for their own experiences, and general responses to the topics I’ve brought up. What always surprises me is when people note the tone of my writing, although I guess it shouldn’t. When I first began discussing my blog and book idea I think people thought I wanted to join the ranks of Deborah Feldman, Noah Feldman and many others and air out my grievances and anger against my frum upbringing. But my initial inspiration actually came from Alain De Botton and his ideas about religious secularism and the hopes that writing would help me strike a personal balance between my secular and Jewish values. I do think I try to reflect my appreciation and respect for the religious experience, while maintaining the awareness that I will continue to lead a secular life. And, honestly, at the end of the day I have very little anger to air out.

Most of you have seen “The Rabbi’s Daughter” by now. It’s a 33 minute film by Racheli Wasserman who chronicles the lives of three women, Rabbi’s daughters, discussing their struggle with their relationship with God juxtaposed with their relationships with their fathers. I think there is a lot to be said on the topic. The filmmaker, herself a Rabbi’s daughter, has clearly inserted so much of her own experience into the work. All in all I think that the viewer gets a very intimate sense of the pain that these women experience, and the harm that their upbringing has done. Obviously this film spoke to me. I found myself nodding in agreement as Tamar Tzohar explained how her family avoided asking religious-themed questions, and when Ruth Katz described her family’s confusion about her religious views.But the heartrending overtones were not something I could personally relate to. To be clear, leaving Orthodoxy was the most painful experience of my life, but my time within Orthodoxy carried little of the burden that these women described.

Sometimes I get the sense that people in the frum community believe that anyone who has “gone off the derech” has experienced trauma. In fact, every time I broach the subject with my mother I find myself reassuring her that no one hurt me. In fact, I’d venture to say that quite the opposite is true. Yes, I was frustrated. A lot. And in retrospect, there are many things about my upbringing I take issue with. But nothing in my religious experience evokes the kind of bitterness or pain I’ve heard others express. I was lucky enough to study at institutions where I found support and even love from Rebbeim and where my creativity and critical thinking were never stifled. The values I got in highschool and (especially in) seminary, in many ways continue to guide me.

So there you have it. No anger. No bitterness. Choosing an alternative isn’t always a rejection of everything that came before.

Monday, October 8, 2012

Happy Mediums and Nostalgia

Almost every Shabbat afternoon on my way home from the gym I walk past the Belz shul on Ahad Haam street. The scene I find there could not be more perfect if it were staged. Two or three Hassidic women in their late twenties or early thirties - always wearing suits of navy, grey, or black and hats perched atop fairly plain wigs - sit and chat on a bench. In stark contrast, there is an unbounded energy present on the playground and basketball court nearby. Young girls, dressed just as modestly but in more liberal styles than their mothers chase each other, jump rope, holler and shriek. Some of the older girls stand in a circle and chatter, many clutching little books of Tehillim. No matter how many times I witness this scene I am struck with an inexplicable mixture of joy and nostalgia. Their world barely resembles the world I grew up with, but the same themes are present. And  I always find myself reaching for my phone to snap a few pictures, but the desire not to trespass or intrude always wins.

In many ways this scene is a symbol of everything leaving observance has caused me to lose. There is something almost pristine about this lifestyle. Carlos Fraenkel put it best (fyi - this article is a must-read):

“When Isaac asks me how I became interested in their world, I tell them that while I am not attracted to its content, I am intrigued by its form—a world that revolves around wisdom and God, rather than wealth, sex, power, and entertainment. They are surprised when I say that from Plato to Spinoza most philosophers endorsed this ranking, if not the same accounts of wisdom and God. And they are stunned to learn that I would be very disappointed if my 2-year-old daughter grew up to value lipstick, handbags, and boys in sports cars more than education and ethics.”

I think my background causes me to be underwhelmed and bored of secular culture. And when I think about any future children I may or may not have, I am a little sad that they will be missing out on the richness of a world that is so thoroughly preoccupied with the internal elements of man instead of the external trappings. So it’s easy to lose sight of the other side of the coin.

In the same article Fraenkel talks about those Hassidim who have rejected the doctrines of their community, but for a variety of reasons remain within it. They must continue to applaud their childrens’ religious-centered accomplishments, although they do not believe in the zealotry and extremism that is an inextricable part of it.

"’It can be heartbreaking,’ Isaac says.’So people in our situation often avoid having more children.’ Although the use of contraception is prohibited in their communities, the issue is not publicly raised and childless couples or couples with fewer children are generally presumed to have medical problems. ‘The worst,’ Isaac says, ‘is if the spouse is not on board.’ He tells me about a friend who stopped having sex altogether because his wife did not agree to using contraception. Jacob points out how harsh an indictment of their world this is: ‘In effect I guess we're saying that it is better not to live at all than to live a Hasidic life.’"

When I first began my departure from observance a friend asked me why I could not simply lead a liberal Modern Orthodox life - glean the positive elements of each world and live in some kind of happy medium. The question has been posed to me a hundred times since and my answer has not changed. I cannot accept the immorality I find within Jewish faith. I cannot be part of a community that believes that homosexuality is an abomination, that the women’s role is so debated, and a hundred other positions that are untenable for me. Each world is flawed, but I choose to make my happy medium on the secular side of the border, and hope that I can sufficiently infuse my life with culture, introspection, and meaning.

But in the meantime I’ll keep walking by the Belz shul yard on Shabbat.

Saturday, September 8, 2012

Sacred and Profane

It's been a while since I've posted, although you readers know that that is not at all uncommon. I had hoped to start posting on a weekly basis, but my computer is broken, family matters have come up and the book is taking up all my writing energies for now. I have started outlining and constructing and should be posting excerpts when I feel more comfortable with it, which may very well be never.

For the past few week I have been listening to lectures from a course by Christine Hayes (a personal hero of mine) on the Hebrew Bible on Yale Open Courseware. I was listening to her lecture on Leviticus and the rituals of the Tabernacle and found myself considering the concepts of sacred and profane in a modern context.

The idea of holiness or sacredness is originally a purely legal and ritual concept. Something which is holy has been designated for use in the service of God, while something profane is something that does not carry that designation. As Hayes points out, profanity in the Bible carries none of the negative connotations of the word that we are used to, it just means common. In other words, a cow which has been designated for sacrifice is now holy and can only be used in a manner befitting holy things; while the same cow, if not designated, can be milked or slaughtered for meat. This designation can exist within many spheres - time, places, objects or people.

We see the idea of spatial holiness most graphically in the tabernacle itself. The outer area is holy, but can be accessed by anyone who is pure (a different ritual designation that we won’t get into now). The next area is separated by a screen and can only be accessed by priests, those designated for performing the ritual rites, and is called the “Kadosh” or The Holy. Further in is the “Kodesh Kodashim” or The Holy of Holies which is where the very presence of God is said to reside. It can only be accessed by the High Priest and only on the holiest of days, Yom Kippur, after a number of purification rituals have been performed. The layout of the tabernacle thereby serves as a clear illustration of the main principle of holiness - greater proximity to God, the ultimate Holy One, renders something more holy and vice versa.

Holiness has come to take on a philosophical significance perhaps not intended by the original authors, but probably more relevant to the average religious practitioner.It came to be more than a legal category, but rather a description of life choices. Especially after the Enlightenment, as the world of the common became larger and more accessible to the Jew, holiness and its role in one’s life became a hotly debated topic.

It is in this milieu that Rav Kook wrote about the roles of the sacred and profane. Instead of viewing them as distinct categories, he posited that they are actually two interdependent elements of kedusha. Without one the other could not exist. He suggests that the people of his time are in such a confusing state because the proponents of each wish to exert dominance over the other. The secular people who lead a “chol” existence wish to make the world wholly secular, while the religious who lead a “kadosh” life would like to convert everyone to their way of life. Only when both realize that they each have an equally vital role in society can either flourish. (Zionism isn’t really my topic here, but clearly Rav Kook was trying to make a point about how a modern State should function, if only today’s leaders had such a “live and let live” philosophy.)

As someone who leads a completely profane life, I wondered how Kook’s philosophy - clearly meant to be prescriptive on a societal level - could translate into personal practice. Is it possible that the sacred and profane elements of me are warring within me trying to find some kind of synthesis?

I believe that for as long as man has been able to perceive and consider his world he has searched for the special and distinct. After all, Judaism did not invent the sacrificial rites and concepts of holiness that we learn about in Leviticus, they borrowed it from the Canaanites who got it from someone before them. This concept of holiness was an effort to cleave to something greater and more transcendent than one’s self, and to find this Other in special times, objects, and people. Perhaps leading a “profane life” may be sad because it means that all is mundane, but then the flip side is that it enables one to decide what is sacred to him. Sacrilegious as it may be, disavowing God means that there is no Other to cleave to and the responsibility lies squarely with me to find meaning in this world (or not to, for that matter.)

Saturday, August 25, 2012

The God of the Intellect

The question of why I have abandoned my faith has been posed to me so many times, that the answer has been chopped down to a few very rehearsed and very vague lines. So today I will attempt to explore the process that began long ago in more detail.

It's not hard to fathom why someone would leave "the fold." Unsightly, not to mention uncomfortable, hemlines and necklines, those pesky dietary laws, and of course sex. So obviously most people assume that comfort and convenience were what I was after, but the truth is that I didn't find Jewish law to be restrictive at all. I thrived in that world. The Aramaic and Hebrew tomes of Halakhic work were my temple, and its practice was my prime mover. In retrospect, I'm not even sure God factored into it at all.

When I was still in the throes of my religious study, I was accused by a friend of mine in a different seminary of not being very "frum." When pressed to actually explain what she was talking about she managed to observe that despite my obvious fidelity to halakha, I was missing the warmth and passion that was associated with real frumkeit. To this day I have no idea what the hell she meant, but she definitely was right on some level. At the time I couldn't admit it. I spent hours frustratedly mulling over and writing about the subject. (It preoccupied me to the point where I literally had nightmares.)

If I remember correctly, I later came to champion this trait of mine. At some point being "not frum" evolved into "not shticky" which was certainly a worthy cause. However, I suppose I can admit that there is something to be said for the person teetering on the fine boundary between homo religiousus and cognitive man.

For those not familiar with Rav Soloveitchik's terminology, I will explain in short. Most of the Rav's philosophy is fixated on a duality that exists within a construct - be it man, community, or a halakha. In "Halakhic Man" he contrasts cognitive man and homo religiousus. Cognitive man is a logical individual who seeks to find order and law in the world around him. He is preoccupied with empirical evidence and solving mysteries. Homo religiousus is wholly preoccupied by mysteries and all that transcends the rigid reason which cognitive man so yearns for. He is not bound by concrete reality and wishes to abandon it for a loftier experience. Soloveitchik explains that the man who deals with halakha (yes, the heroic Halakhic Man for whom the essay is named) is a cognitive man. To him the performance of halakha is secondary to the construction of the theory and system of halakha.

To me, becoming halakhic man was the ideal. I endeavored to study enough of the Talmud that I could truly approach it like a scientist or a mathematician. My friend, however, was taught to relish the experience of religious fervor instead. To be clear, I am not blaming any educational system or institution. If I had been thrown into a school where girls sat in circles on the floor and sang of their God, I would have quickly availed myself of one of the other seminaries available. I only wish to demonstrate how completely unconcerned I was with the feelings one might associate with being religious and how purely intellectual a pursuit it became.

When I reached University and began studying for an academic degree in Talmud, the plethora of questions that had been nagging at me for years were pushed to the forefront of my mind. Suddenly the very seat of my religious devotion - my mind - was turned against halakha. My heart didn't factor into the equation for a moment.

That isn't to say that it wasn't a very emotionally difficult time for me. After all I had been chasing after halakha for as long as I could remember and it was revealing itself to be an illusion. However the moment I decided that empirical reality didn't align with observance, the religious experience became irrelevant. A few short months later I ate on Yom Kippur without so much as a pause or a shudder. Today I am actually shocked at how quickly it all unraveled, but at the time it made perfect sense. I remember discussing it with someone who was going through a similar transformation at the time. Her rebellions against religion came in sudden spurts of energy, one week she found herself wearing pants, the next not waiting between meat and milk and a few weeks later breaking Shabbat. She was deeply bothered by the existence of God and other theological and philosophical questions. I was struck at the novelty of considering God at all for I had been serving on the altar of my intellect the whole time.

Usually I like to tie up my posts with a nice bow at the end. Something learnt or something gained. I don't have any message to take away from this. Perhaps educators who read this will be able to use it to prove that hashkafa and the feelings of observance should play a more prominent role in Jewish education; and I could easily tell them that you could not have made me appreciate the classes with that aim. Others might point out that my story only demonstrates that women shouldn't be given unfettered access to the Talmud; and I simply don't have the energy to respond to such absurdity. In any event, I don't have a take away message, this is simply a descriptive post.

P.S. I keep referring to halakha and Talmud, but that's highly inaccurate. What I really mean is Jewish texts, for Tanach played an equally crucial role in my religion and subsequent denial of it.

P.P.S. If this post seems disjointed and unclear it's because I am writing it at a time of night which can only be described as morning on my iPhone. Sometimes thoughts bubble up until I just have to put them to paper and the hour and medium be damned. So sorry dear readers, you'll have to wait for my book to get a better version of this post.

Thursday, August 9, 2012

The Romance of the Covenantal Community

When I was at the peak of my Torah study days I particularly loved studying from old books. I would breathe in that familiar aroma of decaying paper fibers and hear the creaking of the binding as I opened it and my thoughts would stray to those who had held the book before me. Finding notes in the margins, even if I didn’t understand them, was the absolute jackpot for me. This preoccupation with relics of the past stemmed from my understanding that those who came before me lent meaning to my scholarship.

The Talmud (Menachot 29b) documents a fantastic story:

אמר רב יהודה אמר רב בשעה שעלה משה למרום מצאו להקב"ה שיושב וקושר כתרים לאותיות אמר לפניו רבש"ע מי מעכב על ידך אמר לו אדם אחד יש שעתיד להיות בסוף כמה דורות ועקיבא בן יוסף שמו שעתיד לדרוש על כל קוץ וקוץ תילין תילין של הלכות אמר לפניו רבש"ע הראהו לי אמר לו חזור לאחורך הלך וישב בסוף שמונה שורות ולא היה יודע מה הן אומרים תשש כחו כיון שהגיע לדבר אחד אמרו לו תלמידיו רבי מנין לך אמר להן הלכה למשה מסיני נתיישבה דעתו

Rab Judah said in the name of Rab, When Moses ascended on high he found the Holy One, blessed be He, engaged in affixing coronets to the letters.Said Moses, ‘Lord of the Universe, Who stays Thy hand?’ He answered, ‘There will arise a man, at the end of many generations, Akiba b. Joseph by name, who will expound upon each tittle heaps and heaps of laws’. ‘Lord of the Universe’, said Moses; ‘permit me to see him’. He replied, ‘Turn thee round’. Moses went and sat down behind eight rows [of Rabbi Akiba’s students and listened to the discourses upon the law]. Not being able to follow their arguments he was ill at ease, but when they came to a certain subject and the disciples said to the master ‘Whence do you know it?’ and the latter replied ‘It  is a law given unto Moses at Sinai’ he was comforted.

This short story arises in the context of a Talmudic discussion of the laws of what the letters in a Torah scroll should look like. A more cynical version of myself rejoiced in its absurdity. For starters, an anthropomorphic deity being delayed by the additional little details of calligraphy is beyond amusing. But on a more practical level, this story seemed to prove that even the Sages didn’t believe their recurring assertion that Moses was handed the Torah along with all its laws and customs directly from God.

However, there is a more romantic way to read the story.

Moshe receives the Torah in the most organic and natural way, through prophecy and directly from its Source. However, Rabbi Akiva, the father of the Oral Torah, has a less lucid interaction with the law. He does not converse directly with God, and must instead plumb the seemingly insignificant details of the document to uncover the law. Moshe is engaged in dialogue, while Rabbi Akiva is reading the transcript generations later. Of course Moshe could not understand Rabbi Akiva’s lesson, for he was never forced to rely on the seemingly extraneous details of a document. His only comfort is knowing that even Rabbi Akiva sources himself in Moshe, he is not creating something new, but endeavouring to arrive at the very same Source.

Well, in any event that would be the romantic way to read the story. The Scholars of the Talmud, champions of the Oral Law, envisioning God placing each detail into the text only so that they could uncover the law centuries later. Unfortunately this concept of tradition is no longer one that bears weight with me. In this story alone I might point out that the letters of the Hebrew alphabet underwent a tremendous evolution and that Rabbi Akiva’s letters bore little resemblance to the ones Moshe would have seen God write. I might also point out that Rabbi Akiva’s successors are the ones telling this legend, and as such they might have a vested interest in proclaiming that the methods of their teacher (and subsequently their own methods) were Divinely validated from the get go.

As an Orthodox woman and later on as I attempted to study the Talmud academically, (read: non-traditionally) Tradition was an enemy with a face. He chased, haunted, and berated me. People who would use Talmudic stories such as this one to prove that the Oral Law with all its trappings is an authentic reading of Torah would infuriate me. However, now that Tradition and I have not had much to do with each other for a few years, I can understand why there is so much comfort to be found in his arms and I might once again appreciate some romantic notions about him.

For an Orthodox Jew, the sources he studies are the same ones beheld by Rav Chaim Brisker, The Baal Shem Tov, Rav Yosef Cairo, Hillel and Shammai, Ravina and Rav Ashi and countless others. We all studied the same texts and all hoped that they would transport us back to the original meaning as understood by Moshe as he stood face to face with the Divine. The sources bind us not only with our Creator, but also with each other in an awesome community. I am humbled by my own infinitesimal existence as I consider myself against the backdrop of scholars who preceded me, but I am also aware that this past has allowed me to transcend myself and propels me into a deeper understanding of Torah than I would have been able to accomplish myself. There is solace there when faced with the crisis that is existence.

As a secular woman, there is something empowering about being an individual. Going at the world alone, deciding for yourself what is good and what is evil. No one and nothing binds me and holds me back. But I would be lying if I said that I did not miss my little community of Tradition.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

On the Plight of the Orthodox Feminist

Every week a group of us in Tel Aviv get together to study Jewish History via texts written by different influential figures. Last week I facilitated the group and we covered Rachel Adler’s “The Jew Who Wasn’t There,” an article written by a then Orthodox woman presenting the problems of the conflict between Feminism and Traditional Jewish texts. In the article she details the ways in which the diminished status of women in the eyes of Halakha puts them in a difficult predicament of finding their place in Judaism. She bemoans the fact that traditionally women’s only role was vis a vis their family, husbands, home and community with no option for creating a personal relationship with their God. The models of virtuous women that have arisen through the ages are also found to be limiting for they are usually deemed “Tzaddikot” for their denial of their body, as opposed to the men who are viewed as scholarly and pious and each in their own way. Luckily, she proposes a solution which will save women from their tenuous position - re-reading texts with an empathetic ear to the plight of the woman and creating new precedent which will expand their position in the community.

One line in the article has clawed into my mind and has yet to be shaken free, “All of this can be quickly rectified if one steps outside of Jewish tradition and Halakha.” Since she is writing as a woman who is devoted to the text and to Halakha that is seen as an untenable solution, but she cannot help but note that her frustration and tension only exist if she maintains fidelity to traditional observance. (It is perhaps noteworthy that she eventually finds her spiritual home in the Reform community.) As the group analyzed her writings, my roommate commented that she thought that this position must be impossibly difficult, to reject the conclusion of the Rabbis and yet to remain bound to their word. How would that work? And why would you want it to?

Before I left Jewish observance this was an issue which haunted me. The tomes of Hebrew and Aramaic texts which comprise the Halakha were my primary mover and spiritual home. My goal was to be a Talmudic scholar. And yet, with every turn I found more doors closed to me than open. The troubling thing for me was not just the rampant chauvinism in the community, but rather that this view seemed to have more basis in tradition and Halakha than mine did. Or, to quote a letter I wrote at the peak of my struggles, “What if God really is a sexist?” I understood Adler’s solution of re-reading and re-interpreting texts to allow women to have a more prominent role in Torah and the community, but I was disturbed that special dispensations needed to be made at all. And no amount of apologetics could assuage the pain, for they lacked the history that those who sought to marginalize me had.

When I started on my path towards non-observance, I was spurred by questions that had arisen through my study of the texts and history. However, when I finally decided that my doubts were inextinguishable, I stayed away (and continue to stay away) mainly because of this issue. Why struggle to come to terms with a religion that denies me a place when I can live in a time in which my value is taken for granted?